Franchise FAQ

why is franchise tag bad

by Prof. Maiya Lindgren Published 2 years ago Updated 1 year ago
image

Why do NFL players dread the franchise tag?

  • 1) Say goodbye to leverage The biggest issue is that the tag strips players of almost all leverage during a time when they’re hoping to cash in on big seasons. Getting tagged essentially locks you in with your current team for one year, with little hopes of testing the free agent market. ...
  • 2) There’s no long-term security

For all intents and purposes, the tag forces the player to negotiate on his original team's terms, which usually means sacrificing millions of dollars on a long-term deal or risking his future by playing on a precarious (albeit lucrative) one-year deal.

Full Answer

What is the franchise tag and why is it controversial?

The franchise tag is not usually popular among players. The tag was introduced to protect smaller-market teams from losing free agents to the bigger-market teams, who could historically pay more. However, that is not so much the case anymore. And players can express concerns about having to play another year before getting to sign long-term.

What is the NFL’s franchise tag?

NFL teams have until 4 p.m. ET Monday to inform the league of their decision to franchise a player. As the clock ticks down, For The Win looks at why the franchise tag has become a dreaded title among players. 1. What is it? The franchise tag is given to a player who will otherwise become an unrestricted free agent.

Can an NFL player refuse to play under the franchise tag?

And despite the NFL franchise tag being “guaranteed,” you still need to play in order to get paid. Week 10 is the deadline for players to sign the tag in order to play and collect game checks. For that reason, it’s rare for NFL players to refuse to play under the franchise tag.

What is the difference between a franchise tag and non-exclusive tag?

In contrast, a player given the non-exclusive franchise tag can negotiate with another team. If that team offers the player a contract, the team that tagged him gets the first right of refusal to match the deal. If the team that applied the tag does not match the deal, the new team would send two first-round draft picks to that team.

image

Is NFL franchise tag good or bad?

The jury remains out on the franchise tag. There are obvious advantages for both sides: the teams and players. Teams get to retain a key player, one that likely might appear to be headed out, with relatively minimal negotiating while the players get a nice check to pad their pockets.

Is it good to be franchise tagged?

An exclusive franchise-tagged player gets a guaranteed salary based on the average of the top five salaries at their position during the current year, as opposed to the average of the the top five salaries at a position over the last five years used for a non-exclusive franchise tag, according to Sportingnews.com.

Can you refuse a franchise tag?

Can an NFL player refuse a franchise tag? Yes. We saw Le'veon Bell do it in 2018. It works like this - the player is looking for a specific contract and the team doesn't give it to him.

Is franchise tag guaranteed money?

The player's guaranteed salary for that one season is attractive, but such a tag provides the player no long-term security. A franchise tag still leaves room for negotiation on a long-term contract. The NFL's deadline in 2022 for teams and tagged players to agree upon and sign a multi-year extension remains July 15.

How much do franchise tag players make?

Projected franchise and transition tag numbersPositionFranchise TagTransition TagPositionFranchise TagTransition TagQB$28,598,000$25,651,000DE$20,186,000$16,623,000WR$19,127,000$16,740,0008 more rows•Feb 22, 2022

Why do NFL players not like franchise tag?

Why do NFL players hate the franchise tag? Not all players hate it but most do. The reason they hate it is because it forces them to stay for a fixed price instead of negotiating a contract or leaving the team for somewhere else.

Why does the franchise tag exist?

The franchise tag is a designation NFL teams can apply to one of their upcoming unrestricted free agents per year. Using the franchise tag allows the team to prevent that player from hitting free agency in the new league year.

How does franchise tag affect salary cap?

Franchise or Transition Tag – any player who receives the Franchise or Transition Tag (other than the Exclusive Franchise Tag) is still technically a Free Agent, but is restricted by the Tag. A player under the Tag does count against the Salary Cap, at the amount of the Franchise or Transition Tag tender amount.

Why do NFL players not like the franchise tag?

The most common explanation for why players hate the franchise tag is the lack of security it offers compared with a long-term deal.

Can you trade a franchise tagged player?

No, they cannot be traded. In order for the player to be traded, they would have to be on a contract and be put on the active roster list. Since a franchise player is technically a free agent that is bound by the original team, they are not considered a “signed player”.

Who can be franchise tagged?

Only one player per team, per season, can receive a franchise tag. In order to tag a player for the year, the team must tender a qualifying one-year contract offer. Based on the amount of the offer, the tag is either "exclusive," "non-exclusive" or a "transition" tag.

Why does the franchise tag exist?

The franchise tag is a designation NFL teams can apply to one of their upcoming unrestricted free agents per year. Using the franchise tag allows the team to prevent that player from hitting free agency in the new league year.

Why do NFL teams tag?

Ostensibly, the tag is meant to give teams more time to negotiate long-term deals with important players, but the process can lead to bad feelings and many players would prefer to skip it entirely .

Do NFL players have a long shelf life?

There’s also the matter of financial security. NFL players don’t have a long shelf life, and injuries can derail an entire career in the blink of an eye. Taking advantage of breakout seasons and nailing down guaranteed money for multiple years is a huge priority, especially when players are in the middle of their prime.

Why is the NFL franchise tag so unpopular?

It arguably gives teams an excessive level of control over guys who are on the verge of exploring the open market. A player could be looking at lucrative multi-year offers, suitors that appeal to him, and more guaranteed money. The franchise tag takes all that away from them.

What is the NFL franchise tag?

(Photo by Alex Burstow/Getty Images) The NFL franchise tag is, essentially, a safety net for teams who don’t want to lose a talented player to free agency.

Can you refuse to sign a contract?

Technically, no. But the ramifications of refusing to sign make it an undesirable move.

Why do NFL players use franchise tags?

Following its introduction in 1993, the idea of the tag was to protect small-market franchises that could not compete financially with the bigger teams. However, with that no longer being the case, many players express concern about playing at least another year before they get another opportunity to sign a long-term deal.

What does it mean when an NFL player is given a franchise tag?

The exclusive franchise tag means an NFL player cannot negotiate with another team once the tag has been applied. In contrast, a player who is given the non-exclusive franchise tag can negotiate with another team.

What is the NFL franchise tag?

The franchise tag is a designation NFL teams can apply to one of their upcoming restricted free agents per year. Using the franchise tag allows the team to prevent that player from hitting free agency in the new league year. Only one player can be designated with the franchise tag, and each NFL team must decide between the use of the franchise tag and the transition tag — which has a similar purpose.

How many players can you apply for a franchise tag?

The NFL franchise tag is a designation that teams can apply to one player per year who will be an unrestricted free agent. The franchise tag keeps the player under contract with the franchise that applies the tag for another year. The franchise tag can only be applied to one player per NFL team; teams can only use either the franchise tag or ...

What is franchise tag salary?

Meanwhile, an exclusive franchise tag salary is the average of the top five cap hits at the position following free agency in the new league year. This number is usually determined at a defined date in April.

Why are NFL franchise tags important?

Tags allow teams to buy more time to work on an extension or retain a player for a further year if they believe they are valuable to the team’s success.

What are the different types of franchise tags?

There are two different types of franchise tags that teams can apply. The first is the exclusive franchise tag and the second is the non-exclusive franchise tag.

image
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9